Missouri's two private jails, located in Bethany and Holden, house out-of-state inmates moved as a result of overcrowding. The latter facility was the site of last year's escape. Bill sponsor, Sen. David Pearce, R-Warrensburg, says his legislation ensures all jails that house convicted felons be held accountable for reporting incidents like the one in Holden.
"Right now with these jails there is no accountability, no regulation, no oversight," he said. "What this bill tries to do is at least set standards and not have these sort of rogue prisons that are not part of society."
The bill seeks to hold private jails to the same standards as county jails and state prisons. It also authorizes the state to fine jails which do not report escapes in a "timely" manner, which Pearce said was designed to avoid a repeat of last year's escape.
In September, two prisoners from Kansas City, Kan., escaped from the Holden facility, located in Pearce's district. They escaped around 5 a.m., according to news reports, but Johnson County's sheriff's office was not notified until 1 p.m. that day, and local residents were not informed until even later than that. According to Pearce, it was not even a crime for the prisoners to flee, something he said makes no sense.
"It's not a crime to escape from a private jail," he said. "Once the prison told Johnson County about the escape, the sheriff's office said there was nothing they could do because no crime was committed, and Kansas had to re-introduce charges to arrest them. That's crazy and shouldn't happen again."
The lone dissenter in a 30 to 1 vote Thursday came from Sen. Luann Ridgeway, R-Smithville, who said the bill needed more work before it was brought to the Senate floor for a vote.
"We could have made this bill a lot better," she said. "I really am concerned with the authority that it gives police the right to take over a private facility, when the jail would be responsible for any costs incurred by that."
Ridgeway added that she supports regulating private jails in principle but that she cannot support the unanimous passage of a bill she views as flawed.
"I'm not afraid to be the only one to say no," she said. "A unanimous vote might indicate every single senator thought it was as good as it could be, when that is not the case. There are flaws right now, certainly, but this is not as good as it could be."
Pearce called this legislation "common sense," and said he just wanted to hold jails to standards similar to other private companies.
"What we're trying to do is just give (jails) regulations just like any other business," he said. "I certainly don't want to put these jails out of business; I just want to make them accountable, because right now they aren't."